Work in progress

This page of the documentation is not yet finished and only contains a draft of the content.

Technical specification: solver state#


This document is a technical specification, which might not be the best way to learn about how the solver works. For that, refer to conda install and Solvers.

The Solver API will pass a collection of MatchSpec objects (from now on, we will refer to them as specs) to the underlying SAT solver. How this list is built from the prefix state and context options is not a straightforward process, but an elaborate logic. This is better understood if we examine the ingredients that participate in the construction of specs. We will label them like this:

These groups below will not change during the solver attempts:

  1. requested: MatchSpec objects the user is explicitly asking for.

  2. installed: Installed packages, expressed as PrefixRecord objects. Empty if the environment did not exist.

  3. history: Specs asked in the past: the History. Empty if the environment did not exist.

  4. aggressive_updates: Packages included in the aggressive updates list. These packages are always included in any requests to make sure they stay up-to-date under all circumstances.

  5. pinned: Packages pinned to a specific version, either via pinned_packages in your .condarc or defined in a $PREFIX/conda-meta/pinned file.

  6. virtual: System properties exposed as virtual packages (e.g. __glibc=2.17). They can’t really be installed or uninstalled, but they do participate in the solver by adding runtime constraints.

  7. do_not_remove: A fixed list of packages that receive special treatment by the solver due to poor metadata in the early days of conda packaging. A legacy leftover.

This one group does change during the solver lifetime:

  1. conflicting: Specs that are suspected to be a conflict for the solver.

Also, two more sources that are not obvious at first. These are not labeled as a source, but they do participate in the specs collection:

  • In new environments, packages included in the contex.create_default_packages list. These MatchSpec objects are injected in each conda create command, so the solver will see them as explicitly requested by the user (requested).

  • Specs added by command line modifiers. The specs here present aren’t new (they are already in other categories), but they might end up in the specs list only when a flag is added. For example, update --all will add all the installed packages to the specs list, with no version constraint. Without this flag, the installed packages will still end up in the specs list, but with full constraints (--freeze-installed defaults for the first attempt) unless:

    • Frozen attempt failed.

    • --update-specs (or any other UpdateModifier) was passed, overriding --freeze-installed.

See? It gets involved. We will also use this vocabulary to help narrow down the type of change being done:

Types of spec objects:

  • specs: map of package name to its currently corresponding MatchSpec instance.

  • spec: specific instance of a MatchSpec object.

  • Exact or frozen spec: a spec where both the version and build fields are constrained with == operators (exact match).

  • Fully constrained or tight spec: a spec where both version and build are populated, but not necessarily with equality operators. It can also be inequalities (>, <, etc.) and fuzzy matches (*something*).

  • Version-only spec: a spec where only the version field is populated. The build is not.

  • Name-only, bare, or unconstrained spec: a spec with no version or build fields. Just the name of the package.

  • Targeted spec: a spec with the target field populated. Extracted from the comments in the solver logic:

    target is a reference to the package currently existing in the environment. Setting target instructs the solver to not disturb that package if it’s not necessary. If the is being modified by inclusion in specs_to_add, we don’t set target, since we want the solver to modify/update that package.

    TL;DR: when working with MatchSpec objects,

    • to minimize the version change, set MatchSpec(name=name, target=prec.dist_str())

    • to freeze the package, set all the components of MatchSpec individually

  • if the spec object does not have an adjective, it should be assumed it’s being added to the specs map unmodified, as it came from its origin.

Pools (collections of PackageRecord objects):

  • Installed pool: The installed packages, grouped by name. Each group should only contain one record!

  • Explicit pool: The full index, but reduced for the specs in requested.

The following sections will get dry and to the point. They will state what output to expect from a given set of initial conditions. At least we’ll try. Take into account that the specs list is kept around across attempts! In other words, the specs list is only really empty in the first attempt; if this fails, the subsequent attempts will only overwrite (update) the existing one. In practice, this should only affect how constrained packages are. The names should be the same.

It will also depend on whether we are adding (conda install|create|update) or removing (conda remove) packages. There’s a common initialization part for both, but after that the logic is separate.

Common initialization#

Note: This happens in Solver._collect_all_metadata()

This happens regardless of the type of command we are using (install, update, create or remove).

  1. Add specs from history, if any.

  2. Add specs from do_not_remove, but only if:

    • There’s no spec for that name in specs already, and

    • A package with that name is not installed.

  3. Add virtual packages as unconstrained specs.

  4. Add all those installed packages, as unconstrained specs, that satisfy any of these conditions:

    • The history is empty (in that case, all installed packages are added)

    • The package name is part of aggresive_updates

    • The package was not installed by conda, but by pip or other PyPI tools instead.

Preparing the index

At this point, the populated specs and the requested specs are merged together. This temporary collection is used to determine how to reduce the index.

Processing specs for conda install#


  1. Generate the explicit pool for the requested specs (via Resolve._get_package_pool()).

  2. Detect potential conflicts (via (Resolve.get_conflicting_specs()).

Refine specs that match installed records#

  1. Check that each of specs match a single installed package or none! If there are two or more matches, it means that the environment is in bad shape and is basically broken. If the spec matches one installed package (let’s call it installed match), we will modify the original spec.

  2. We will turn the spec into an exact (frozen) spec if:

    1. The installed match is unmanageable (installed by pip, virtual, etc.)

    2. There’s no history, we are not in --freeze-installed mode, and:

      • The spec is not a potential conflict, and

      • The package name cannot be found in the explicit pool index or, if it is, the installed match can be found in that explicit pool (to guarantee it will be found instead of creating one more conflict just because).

  3. We relax the spec to a name-only spec if it’s part of the aggressive updates list.

  4. We turn it into a targeted spec if:

    1. The spec is in history. In that case, we take its historic spec counterpart and set the target to the installed match version and build.

    2. None of the above conditions were met. In other words, we’ll try our best to match the installed package if none of the above applies, but if we fail we’ll stick to whatever was already present in the specs.

Handle pinned specs#

Processing specs for conda remove#